While learning about ideological periods of literature, I was told that we were living in a “post-truth world" in my AP Literature class in twelfth grade. Just from the sound of the name of that phrase, I had a foreboding sense that it could not be a good thing.
Gradually, I learned that a post-truth world is one where the credibility of facts is so eroded that facts become negotiable. “Objectivity” becomes much less influential in shaping public opinion than personal beliefs, emotions, and political affiliations– people are less concerned about whether something is true and rather whether it feels true.
The obvious problem with a post-truth society is that, well… Truth exists.
Sure, not everything can be neatly divided into facts and opinions. Some thoughts and feelings exist in between them along a spectrum between truth and interpretations.
Yet, that is also the most frightening thing about post-truthism: it encourages us to scream our opinions so loudly within that ambiguous space that they spill over into what is objectively true, obscuring the boundary between fact and opinion. Disagreement with our opinions gradually becomes indistinguishable from an attack on our identities. Eventually, we forget that there was a truth to begin with, abandoning whatever reservations we once had about the limits of our own knowledge, the credibility of our sources, and the strength of our arguments.
But the very notion of post-truthism seems so absurd: how can we humans, as a species priding itself on being the evolutionary winner of complex thought and reasoning, abandon all sensibilities and turn into such irrational beings?
The first indication for how we got here might be in the way we learn about the world. I remember classrooms where children would gather around and read the Guinness World Records, or National Geographic. Teachers recommended those readings, trusting that the information printed on their pages had been researched, verified, and deemed worth sharing. We rarely questioned who had selected these stories or why we should believe them. The authority of the publication itself was enough. Today, however, even that seemingly straightforward relationship between information and credibility has become more complicated: we are more aware that what we read is shaped by who publishes it, who funds it, and whose interests it serves.
Because of it, established institutions are increasingly expected to defend not only their findings but also their motives, methods, and credibility. The emotional distance and high barrier to access they once held now proves to be the bane of their existence– the public trusts an influencer with a compelling personal story detailing their “origin story”, “GRWMs (get-ready-with-me)” that walk through their methods and thought process, and their millions of subscribers that allow them to be associated with expertise without traditional credentials, over the distant “expert” whose jargons they do not understand, knowledge they could not verify, and loyalties they could not identify.
The rise of social media has not changed our need for an objective voice, only who we perceive is the source of that objectivity. Today, the vague notion of “expertise” alone is no longer enough to earn someone's trust.
More recently, artificial intelligence (AI) has made it harder than ever to distinguish what to trust. Whereas videos and photos were once considered a reliable form of documentation that is much harder to manipulate convincingly than words, generative AI has made it so that this visual and audio evidence cannot only be fabricated but also tailored to individual needs.
Unlike how traditional photoshopping required technical skills, time to produce convincing changes, and source materials that bear close resemblance to the intended change, generative AI lowered the barrier so that images, videos, and even recordings could be distorted to fit the manipulator’s agenda without the same limitations.
Now, with the mass scale of AI, viewers are constantly scrutinizing every video and image for signs of AI use, fundamentally changing our relationship with evidence. In this three-way attack on our trust in institutions, individuals, and even the material we come across, the very foundations on which we establish what is true become increasingly unstable.
Yet, amidst all this skepticism, there is one industry that seems to have figured something out. An industry where doctors contradict each other, scientists have differing opinions, and evidence is frequently cherry-picked. Yet consumers continue to believe and purchase from them.
What does the wellness industry do right that the rest of the science community has not quite figured out?
Wellness communicators are experts in personal communication, particularly in bringing what would traditionally be backstage conversations to the front stage. As they share anecdotes of personal insecurities and everyday concerns, viewers feel like their needs are being seen, and they specifically are being identified and talked to, even when knowing that the video might be intended for millions of viewers. Here, the science is not just distant statistics or figures that “limits the validity of the data”, but tangible potential solutions to a real-life problem. Consumers know the limitations, yet would still like to try the evidence-based approach.
This is particularly effective in a post-truth society. When institutions are weakened, individuals seek comfort in familiar faces that are among “one of the people”, those that can articulate their concerns and understand their struggles in a way the establishment has failed to.
These familiar wellness communicators will then end their videos with clear instructions that give people something to do: drink more water, take a walk, change your breakfast, or establish a nighttime routine.
Here, science is no longer a collection of distant facts and figures, but something tangible that viewers feel would improve their lives. While recommendations might not always be scientifically accurate, they offer people what they crave most in a post-truth world: agency.
This is perhaps where scientific communication has the most to learn from. There is a difference between telling someone that exercise is associated with improved cardiovascular health and showing them how to incorporate exercise movement into their daily lives. Science will do well to remember that ordinary people need a lot more hand-holding.
Of course, there is an important distinction between learning from the wellness industry's communication strategies and adopting its business model. Science cannot afford to promise certainty where none exists, manufacture personal transformations, or present preliminary findings as universal truths. Its responsibility is fundamentally different. But perhaps its commitment to accuracy has sometimes come at the expense of accessibility.
Science is one of the few things in life that actively teaches us to question what we believe. It is built on skepticism and a willingness to change one's mind when presented with better evidence. Yet these very qualities are dampened in a post-truth world where people are unconcerned with nuance.
In a post-truth world, pursuing truth is no longer enough. We must also learn how to make people care about it.