A friend of mine recently admitted that she sometimes feels embarrassed by how little she has figured out. Not because anything particularly terrible has happened to her, but rather because everyone else seems to be moving forward in some discernible direction. People seem to be getting internships, falling in love, and making big plans for their futures all around. Meanwhile, she told me, she’s still undecided about a career, stuck in an unsure situationship, and occasionally spending an entire Sunday wondering what she’s doing with her life.
I knew exactly what she meant. There’s a very peculiar embarrassment in being young and not having much to show for it, especially living in New York City, where the hustle culture is inescapable, and everyone around you seems to turn every day of their lives into something that’s actually worth documenting. We laughed about the situation, and I admitted that I’ve found myself feeling a similar way as well. The conversation has stuck with me since. When did being a little lost become something we as women needed to apologize for? When did an ordinary amount of confusion for a young person start to feel like a personal shortcoming?
There is something decidedly unfashionable about a woman who has absolutely nothing going for her. Not in the romantic and cinematic sense of a woman on the brink of reinvention – I am not referring to the heartbroken woman who cuts her bangs, moves to Paris, and magically appears with a fabulous apartment and wardrobe despite being an aspiring ceramicist –, but an actual loser. A girl with no five-year plan, no impressive career prospects, and no idea of what should come next. Someone who makes legitimate mistakes, changes her mind, and has very little to show for her adulthood so far. Whatever happened to her?
For a while, pop culture seemed perfectly fine with the accommodation of this type of woman. Think Hannah Horvath in Lena Dunham’s Girls, Phoebe Waller-Bridge’s Fleabag or Greta Gerwig’s Frances Halladay in Frances Ha. Fleabag sabotages her own relationships, Frances drifts about her twenties with little to no direction and financial stability, and Hannah is so consumed with herself that she barely pays attention to those around her. These characters were broke, confused, selfish, horrible with relationships, and frankly incapable of making consistent good decisions. None of them were aspirational, which was rather the point. They weren’t necessarily people you’d want to be close friends with, but they were definitely relatable to a fault for many women, and therefore, good entertainment.
When Girls premiered in 2012, Hannah Horvath became the subject of an almost disproportionate amount of cultural scrutiny. She was selfish, entitled, narcissistic, and unbearable. But television had spent decades allowing men to be all these things without it becoming a cultural debate. In fact, the male leads in some of the most popular shows of all time were horrible people. Tony Soprano, Walter White, the Roy family, and Dexter Morgan (just to name a few) are protagonists of some of the most popular TV shows of all time and still considered to be compelling and often rooted for by their audiences. The directionless male antihero could spend entire seasons unemployed, emotionally unavailable, and being a generally horrible person without anyone demanding that he be a better representative of his gender in the media. Hannah, meanwhile, seemed to require a defense. Why was it so difficult to let a woman be annoying?
It’s possible the problem is that female empowerment has gradually become synonymous with female excellence. Women can do anything, we’re told, provided that what we do is impressive. We should have fulfilling careers, healthy relationships, financial independence, interesting hobbies, excellent skincare routines, and the emotional intelligence to recognize when someone isn’t treating us well. The rebranding of the ideal woman in the modern world is really fascinating. Even our failures have become strangely productive. A bad relationship is a lesson in boundaries. A terrible job becomes an opportunity to discover true passions. A humiliating night out should be used as an anecdote on personal growth. We’re encouraged to turn practically every shitty experience into something useful.
However, sometimes a man is just an idiot. Sometimes, you are an idiot. You can quite literally spend an entire summer making bad decisions and learn absolutely nothing from it. And I believe there should be room for that. Of course, there are reasons we as a society have become so invested in celebrating successful women. For generations, women were denied the professional opportunities, financial independence, and personal freedoms routinely afforded to men. The insistence that women can be ambitious, powerful, and intellectually accomplished was and still is necessary. But there’s a difference between having the opportunity to succeed and being expected to succeed. Somewhere between the two, the language of empowerment acquired a rather exhausting set of expectations.
Maybe there’s a specific reason we’ve all become so obsessed with fixing ourselves. Catherine Rottenberg’s writing on neoliberal feminism, where she explores how contemporary feminism can become entangled with the language of individual responsibility and self-management. Structural inequalities are reframed as problems that individual women must overcome through better choices, better planning, and better versions of themselves. It’s an interesting contradiction considering that we’ve spent decades arguing that women shouldn’t have to organize their lives around others, only to replace that expectation with the demand that they become endlessly useful to themselves. We have to invest in ourselves. Enter new eras. Reset our lives to become the best version of ourselves. At what point did being a person have to be a full-time job?
It’s crucial to note that male failure is treated completely differently. There’s an entire subsection of media devoted to men who cannot get their lives together. The unemployed musician, failed writer, emotionally stunted bachelor. Their inability to function is considered charming and existential. A man who doesn’t know what he wants is just figuring things out, while a woman who doesn’t know what she wants needs to do self reflection and work on herself. Men are allowed to be ordinary without having to justify it. Meanwhile, women are still negotiating the consequences of having historically been denied so many opportunities to the point where every opportunity feels mandatory, resulting in a strange paradox where women have been told they can do anything, but are rarely allowed to be bad at anything.
I think about this particularly in the context of your late teens & early twenties. We’re told these are our years to travel, experiment, fall in love, establish careers, build friendships and enjoy self-discovery. We’re supposed to enjoy being young but make sure we don’t waste our potential and precious time in the process, which frankly is a lot to ask of people still eating Lean Cuisine and dining hall food for dinner. Perhaps this is why returning to Girls or Frances Ha is so appealing. These stories understood that a woman could be the protagonist of her own life without being a role model or representing her generation in a positive light. Judith Halberstam’s The Queer Art of Failure challenges conventional ideas of achievement/productivity and what constitutes a worthwhile life. Perhaps the female loser offers a similar alternative to the increasingly narrow definition of what a successful woman looks like.
I don’t think women should aspire to unhappiness or that financial insecurity is a glamorous feminist statement. Nor do I think ambition is inherently unfeminist. I admire ambitious women. I’d like to think that I myself am one. I just don’t think the alternative should be treated as some big tragedy. It is arguably sad that there’s such a big idea on how every version of ourselves must be temporary or that the girl who doesn’t know what she wants is simply waiting to become one who does. That the bad dates, dead-end jobs, embarrassing nights and wasted mornings are only worthwhile if they eventually lead to a better life. What if they don’t? Is it such a horrible idea that not every moment in our lives needs to result in some form of character development? Perhaps we’ve become so preoccupied with the finished project that we’ve forgotten there's something to be said for the unfinished woman who’s still figuring it out, who hasn’t yet lived up to her potential and may never become extraordinary. I don’t think she needs another makeover, 30-step morning routine, or another inspirational podcast to “fix” her.
I think she just needs to be left alone.